+The Government Used a Hotel to Explain “Surveillance Pricing.” The Industry Would Like a Word.
Every hotel owner already practices price discrimination. Economists just don’t say it that way at parties.
A room on a Tuesday in February costs less than the same room on New Year’s Eve. A guest who books six months out pays a different rate from one who walks in at midnight. A loyalty member gets a discount a stranger doesn’t. None of this is sinister. Rooms are perishable. An empty one tonight is worth zero tomorrow, and prices move to fill them.
So it was striking when the Federal Trade Commission, explaining what kind of pricing might cross the line, included a hotel among its examples.
The funeral example
In August, the FTC proposed an enforcement policy on what it calls personalized pricing: using an individual’s personal data to set the price that person sees. The agency said it does not have the authority from Congress to ban the practice outright. But it said that if consumers reasonably expect a price not to depend on their personal data, a business that personalizes it should clearly say so, explain the basis and name the kinds of data it used. Failing to, the FTC said, would likely violate the law against unfair and deceptive practices. Fuzzy phrases like “specially selected” pricing would not count as disclosure.
Its examples of what could get a company in trouble include food delivery, groceries and this one: a hotel that charges a guest more because it infers the guest is traveling for a funeral.
It is a perfect example for a regulator, because it is easy to picture and impossible to defend. The question is how many hotels actually do anything like it.
The industry’s answer
This week, the American Hotel & Lodging Association made its case. Writing in LODGING, Chirag Shah, AHLA’s senior vice president of federal affairs and policy counsel, argued that policymakers keep using three different ideas as if they were one.
Dynamic pricing is rates moving with demand, supply and how far ahead someone books. Algorithmic pricing is software doing that math. Personalized pricing, the thing some critics call “surveillance pricing,” uses data about a specific person to set a price aimed at them. Shah also drew a line around member and loyalty rates, corporate and group rates, and government and military rates. In his view, those use customer data to decide who qualifies for a lower price, not to push a guest’s price as high as it will go.
AHLA agrees transparency matters when personal data actually leads to a higher price. But it wants disclosure rules aimed only there. Otherwise, Shah warned, a hotel could end up posting a warning label on a member discount, and guests would reasonably conclude they were being overcharged when they were being given a deal.
He has a point. So does the FTC. The problem is that guests can’t tell the difference, and that is exactly what makes the issue politically potent.
Keep reading
Keep reading with full access: a 24-hour Day Pass is $1.39, or $1.99 your first month, then $3.99/mo — or $19.95/year (Save $27.93 a year vs. $3.99/mo, about 58%).
Already a member? Log in

Comments
No comments yet. Start the conversation.